Looking back, I found that I used the liquid liner more just because it allowed me to make very fine, precise lines. Especially when i wanted go for the winged liner look~ It's also really good at staying put for the entire day. But the downside is that it is just not quite as black as i want it to be, and also dries out quite quickly. (I have been using this a lesser amount of time compared to my stila liquid liner, but that one is still going strong.) On the other hand, the pencil liner really lives up to its name and does not budge after u apply it. This can definitely be a good and bad thing. The advantage is pretty obvious, but it can be a bad thing because it makes it hard to achieve the smokey eye look cuz it just wouldn't smudge. The pencil liner is also quite water proof, as u can see from the picture below:
pencil on the left and liquid on the right~ The liquid does not come out that thick i promise, it's just because it is almost drying out that i had to draw harder on my hand...the actual thickness is about 1/4 of that line i drew above. sorry for it being a bit misleading ^^"
and thennnnnnnn after some epic rubbing on my hand...
So as you can see the pencil one totally outlasted the liquid one~ They are both good eyeliners in my opinion, but just make sure u have a good eye make up remover to go along with these, or else it would take a while before they would come off.~ over all i would give these eyeliners a 8.5/10 and would definitely repurchase if i could get my hands on them! ヽ(*・ω・)ﾉ
